Is Shopify right for a local shop?
Looking for something simpler? Discover our Shopify alternative, with no commission, designed for makers.
Published on , updated on 5 min read The 123Ventes team

You run a shop: a delicatessen, a bookshop, a florist, a clothing or home decor shop. Your customers come through the door, you know them, some of them for years. And one day, one of them asks you: “Do you sell online too?”
The first name that comes to mind is Shopify. Fair enough: it is the platform everyone talks about. But Shopify was designed first and foremost for brands that sell online, everywhere, in large quantities. A neighbourhood shop does not have quite the same needs. Let’s look at what fits, and what does not.
What Shopify does well for a physical shop
Let’s be honest: Shopify is not a bad choice for a shopkeeper. It has real strengths.
- In-store pickup and local delivery are built in: the customer orders online and comes to collect the parcel, or you deliver within a radius you choose.
- A point-of-sale system, Shopify POS, lets you take payments in the shop using the same stock as the website. Sell an item at the counter and it disappears from the website. Handy when you only have one of a vase or a signed book.
- Payments are ready to go: card, Apple Pay, Google Pay, without having to negotiate with your bank.
- The website is robust: it handles traffic, it is fast, it displays well on phones.
If you have several shops, a large catalogue and the ambition to grow your online sales significantly, Shopify can do it.
The problem: a tool built for other volumes
Where things get tricky is that most small shops will not sell thousands of parcels a month. The website is there first and foremost to be found, to reassure, to reserve a product or to help out the customer who cannot come in. And for that role, Shopify is often bigger than the need.
An example: a neighbourhood wine merchant puts 80 bottles online. She gets about ten orders a month through the website, mostly for in-store pickup, and a few more at Christmas. She needs neither a sales funnel optimised for international markets nor fifteen apps. She needs it to be simple, to work, and not to cost more than it brings in.
The real cost for a small shop
The advertised price of Shopify Basic is €27 a month with an annual commitment, or €36 a month without one. But for a shop, you need to look at what comes on top:
- apps: customer reviews, appointment booking, product options, translation… often between €5 and €20 a month each;
- the till: the free version of Shopify POS is limited, and the Pro version, with detailed stock and staff management, is charged on top, per location;
- the card terminal for the shop, bought separately;
- the 2% commission if you keep your bank’s payment provider instead of Shopify Payments.
For a shop doing a few thousand euros of online sales a year, these costs can quickly eat up a good share of the website’s margin. It is not a scam, it is written in the pricing. It is just that the price list was designed for shops that sell far more.

Time: the resource shopkeepers do not have
The most underestimated cost is time. Between opening up, supplier deliveries, the window display, the accounts and the customers, there are rarely two hours a day left to set up a theme, compare apps and read the English documentation of a shipping module.
Shopify has a reputation for being simple, and it is, for someone who enjoys these tools. For a shopkeeper who just wants their products online, the list of settings can be off-putting. Many open an account during the free trial, put in two evenings… and then leave it dormant.
Questions to ask yourself before choosing
- How many online orders do I realistically expect each month? Ten, a hundred, a thousand? The answer changes everything.
- Are my customers mostly local? If so, in-store pickup and a good Google profile matter more than a sophisticated website.
- Do I need a till linked to the website? If you have few unique items, updating the stock by hand may be enough at first.
- Who is going to look after it? You, an employee, your tech-savvy nephew? And what happens when he goes on holiday?
- How much am I prepared to pay a year, all in? Subscription, apps, hardware and commissions.
For the local side, we have written a complete guide: how to sell locally online.
An alternative designed for local shops
It is precisely for these shopkeepers that we created 123Ventes. The shop comes fully equipped: card, PayPal and bank transfer payments, delivery options, in-store pickup, domain name and hosting included. The subscription is €29.90 a month, or €319.90 a year, with no apps to add and no commission on your sales.
And if you really do not have the time, we can set the shop up for you: you send us your photos and prices, and we take care of the rest. When you have a question, you write to a real person, in French.
For a detailed comparison, read our page Shopify alternative, with the real cost over a year, and if you still go with Shopify, avoid the 8 beginner mistakes. Comparing with Wix too? See our Wix alternative.
Conclusion
Shopify suits small shops that want to make online selling a genuine second business, with the time and budget for it. For the neighbourhood shop that mainly wants to be visible, take orders for pickup and help out its loyal customers, it is often a lot of tool for little use.
The right choice is the one you will actually use, without spending your evenings on it.
👉 Try 123Ventes for free and see if it suits you.